Post by StuckOnTwins on Jul 19, 2014 1:11:35 GMT
Okay, I HAVE to rant. I watched this show when it first started because I had read the books. However, I stopped watching when I found out they were not going with the Ali/Courtney twin thing. But recently I began to re-watch the entire series up until the latest episode season 4, episode 6. I can't let go of the twin theory despite what they say. I know there are hints all around such as pictures in the DiLaurentis house as well as the poster in Ali's room. But my thoughts stem from what the characters say and do.
First of all, Bethany Young being a twin of either Ali or Jason would explain why Mrs. DiLaurentis was at Radley. It would also them explain why Bethany disliked Mrs. D and expressed it in the picture given to Ezra. Also, since when are police not able to get medical information on a case like that? They should easily be able to get a warrant for it but everyone is so hush hush. Plus the night Ali "died", her mother was speaking on the phone with someone, sounding like it was someone she knew well and basically telling them to hurry to get there. That could have been Bethany. And Bethany (being the twin) could have hit Ali with the rock and Mrs. D buried Ali to protect her other daughter. I'm still at a loss as to how Bethany got into the grave unless, like in the book, the twins were switched. Lastly, if Bethany was not an identical twin of Alison or even at least a relative, how would a coroner make that mistake? They're jobs are designed strictly for identifying bodies and figuring out what killed them. Surely, more than just broken bone could have separated the two girls.
I don't know, those are my thoughts. Maybe I'm reading much to into it but if they don't have a twin in the show I will be disappointed as that's what made the books ending so interesting.
All I can say as a positive is I hope Ezra and Aria get back together and stay that way for good. <3 I'm obsessed with Ezaria.
First of all, Bethany Young being a twin of either Ali or Jason would explain why Mrs. DiLaurentis was at Radley. It would also them explain why Bethany disliked Mrs. D and expressed it in the picture given to Ezra. Also, since when are police not able to get medical information on a case like that? They should easily be able to get a warrant for it but everyone is so hush hush. Plus the night Ali "died", her mother was speaking on the phone with someone, sounding like it was someone she knew well and basically telling them to hurry to get there. That could have been Bethany. And Bethany (being the twin) could have hit Ali with the rock and Mrs. D buried Ali to protect her other daughter. I'm still at a loss as to how Bethany got into the grave unless, like in the book, the twins were switched. Lastly, if Bethany was not an identical twin of Alison or even at least a relative, how would a coroner make that mistake? They're jobs are designed strictly for identifying bodies and figuring out what killed them. Surely, more than just broken bone could have separated the two girls.
I don't know, those are my thoughts. Maybe I'm reading much to into it but if they don't have a twin in the show I will be disappointed as that's what made the books ending so interesting.
All I can say as a positive is I hope Ezra and Aria get back together and stay that way for good. <3 I'm obsessed with Ezaria.